| Newspaper Article:
The Baltimore Sun
March 2005
"The Sleep Lady, Kim West of Annapolis, brings slumber
to fitful toddlers"
From the normally placid book-signing corner of the Barnes &
Noble at the Festival at Woodholme come the murmurs of parents desperate
for a decent night’s sleep.
One 15-month-old boy has never slept through the night, his mother
admits. A 5-month-old girl drifts off on her own – but is
wailing after 10 minutes, says another woman. A baby delays bedtime
by angrily throwing her favorite stuffed duck. What to do about
the day care center where all the kids have to sleep at the same
time – so one has to nap, poorly, in a bouncy seat?
The Sleep Lady – otherwise known as Kim West, an Annapolis
social worker turned guru of children’s rest – stands
in a dark suit at the center of this confessional. After building
a consulting practice that has exhausted parents from around the
country paying $125 an hour for evaluations and morning phone calls,
West has written a book that offers a “gentle” way to
get kids sleeping on their own.
If she needed any further evidence that we are a sleep-deprived
nation, the book’s promotional tour has provided it. The Pikesville
signing is tame. “In Annapolis,” West recalls, “three
women were crying.”
With Good Night, Sleep Tight: The Sleep Lady’s Gentle Guide
to Helping Your Child Go to Sleep, Stay Asleep and Wake Up Happy
(CDS Books, $22.95), West is the latest to enter the never-ending
debate over how best to get children to sleep.
Parents often struggle with conflicting sleep advice. Should they
use the Ferber method of leaving children alone to cry, with intermittent
checks? The “attachment parenting” model that encourages
parents and babies to sleep in the same bed?
The numbers show that, for many, nothing is working. A poll released
last year by the National Sleep Foundation found that more than
two0thirds of children have one or more sleep problems at least
a few nights a week. In every age group from infants through fifth-graders,
the average amount of sleep that children were getting fell below
the minimum amount recommended by experts.
Doing the ‘shuffle’
Many kids are going to bed too late, says Dr. Marc Weissbluth,
a pediatric sleep researcher whose popular book Healthy Sleep Habits,
Happy Child (Ballentine Books, $14.95) emphasizes the importance
of children’s sleep cycles.
“You have more children kept up too late because the parents
are coming home wanting to play with their child,” he says.
The fact that parents also are usually tired makes it less likely
that they will follow any method consistently, Weissbluth says.
With co-author Joanne Kenen, a former client, West advocates what
she calls a “middle road” approach. It involves allowing
kids 6 months and older to cry – while parents stay in the
room with them.
She calls it “The Sleep Lady Shuffle.” It can take
as long as two weeks.
First, the parent sits next to the crib and intermittently pats
and talks to the child until she goes to sleep – as long as
that takes. To keep the baby from being overly entertained by this,
West recommends that the adult close his or her own eyes. “Don’t
stimulate him,” she writes of the baby. “Bore him.”
After a few days, the parent moves the chair halfway to the door.
Then, to the doorway. By night 10, Mom or Dad is sitting in the
hallway.
Three nights after that, parents can usually do what they like
– as long as they’re on the same floor, listening for
the baby to cry.
Two prominent sleep experts said the West’s “shuffle,”
is similar to “fadeaway” techniques that have been used
for years.
“It works for some children and utterly fails for some,”
Weissbluth said. “Any piece of advice has to be temperament-specific,
age-specific. There’s no cookie-cutter approach that works
for every family.”
Dr. William Sears, author of many books on attachment parenting,
said he recommends a similar method for parents who want an older
child to leave their bed for his own room. But Sears is leery of
doing it much before a child is a year old. “Fading away too
fast, too young is risky, because a child loses trust,” he
said.
‘She’s controlling me’
West, 40, became interested in children’s sleep around the
time she thought about having her own. She began to read everything
she could on the subject, and got both of her daughters to sleep
for eight-hour stretches before they were 3 months old. A word-of-mouth
practice grew, and a decade later, West estimates she has helped
at least 1,000 families.
Her recommendations didn’t work in fewer than 5 percent
of cases, she says. For those children, the problem is sometimes
a hidden medical condition, or disagreement between the parents
over the best sleep strategy.
“If a parent is really 100 percent consistent, the problem
goes away,” West says.
For those who hire her, West takes an extensive history of the family
and its sleep habits to develop an individual “sleep plan.”
She schedules morning phone consultations to go over how the child
slept the night before.
She tells parents they are “sleep coaches,” not trainers
– that, in the familiar terms of the little league soccer
match, they can encourage and teach, but it’s up to the child
to make the goal.
Her advice worked for Kristin Miller of Monkton, whose daughter
Sarah was waking up earlier and earlier as a toddler to be nursed
back to sleep in her parents’ bed.
“I tried the Ferber method and I just could not stand to hear
her cry like that,” said Miller, 34. “She was a very
stubborn child, and she would cry as long as we would let her. I
just was not committed to it. I just thought, this is so mean.”
But when she sat next to Sarah’s crib and watched her cry
– for an hour and a half the first morning – she realized
that her daughter wasn’t suffering, just angry about having
to sleep on her own. “It kind of clicked with me that she’s
controlling me,” Miller said. “She knows I’m her,
that I’m not abandoning her.”
Affirming postcards
When Kathy Cavanaugh of Bowie hired West, her toddler daughter
was staying up later while her twin brother woke at 1 a.m. to sleep
with his parents. They wouldn’t nap at day care.
West recommended moving the twins’ bedtime to between 7
and 7:30 p.m. and doing the “shuffle.” Cavanaugh, 42,
was surprised to see that one twin’s crying didn’t wake
the other. After some rough nights – including the first one,
when daughter Nicole ended up in her parents’ bed after hours
of fussing – the twins are sleeping well.
“There’s no doubt that the payoff is worth it,”
Cavanaugh said. “I think they’re healthier and happier.”
Lisa Agius of Towson, one of the sleep-deprived mothers at the
Pikesville book signing, bought West’s book that night and
quickly read it. She was determined to get her 11-month-old daughter,
Ella – who she describes as “a bit headstrong”
– to stop waking up at night.
Agius steeled herself for the task. She wrote out four affirming
postcards to look at in Ella’s room, as West suggests, to
keep herself from caving in. One read: “Sleep equals sleep.”
The first night, Ella woke at 1:30 a.m. – and cried until
she fell asleep at 4. Her mother sat beside her all the while.
But by the third night, the baby cried just 10 minutes after a
middle-of-the-night wakeup before drifting off again. And the fifth
night, she slept until morning. Teething has awakened her a few
times since then, but Agius was hopeful.
“I could see, even in the first three nights that she was
starting to realize that, you know what? I think Mom means business
this time.”
Tips from the Sleep Lady
- Follow an age-appropriate daily routine for meals, naps and
bedtime
- Keep a running sleep diary that describes how many times a
child woke at night, and how you responded. It will be easier
to remember what happened in the morning, and to address problems.
- Follow the method without resorting to crutches like nursing
or rocking a child to sleep. Consistency is key.
- Encourage a child’s attachment to a “lovey”
such as a stuffed animal or other transitional object. He can
snuggle against it in the middle of the night to help himself
back to sleep.
- If your child hasn’t napped at all and needs to, don’t
be afraid to take her for a car ride or a walk in the stroller
if it’s the only way she’ll sleep.
- Make sure you and your spouse agree on how you will approach
sleep problems – before the middle of the night.
- Get the rest you need. You’ll be a better model for your
children.
BACK TO
TOP
|